Transnational criminal proceedings, witness evidence and confrontation: Lessons from the ECtHR's case law

A single European area of freedom, security and justice requires new models of judicial cooperation in criminal matters to be put in place in order to efficiently combat transnational organized crime. However, this should not be done while disregarding the protection of the individual rights of the suspect and the accused: a transnational criminal procedure should not entail a lowering of the procedural safeguards identified by the European Court of Human Rights. The tension between the efficiency in the cooperation and the need to protect the fundamental rights of the defendant is particularly visible in matters of the transnational gathering of evidence, its transfer and its admissibility as evidence against the accused. This paper intends to identify general principles and rules that should be applied in European transnational criminal proceedings with regard to witness evidence. Departing from the ECHR’s case law, this paper will try to identify the principles regarding the hearing of witnesses who reside in another Member State, the admissibility of pre-trial statements as evidence and the need to foster the use of the live video link for witness questioning.

Journal/Publisher: Utrecht Law Review, Volume 9, Issue 4

Publication type: Article

Number of pages/Page range: 127-146

Language/s (content): English

Date of publication: 26-09-13

Personal data

Full name Lorena BACHMAIER-WINTER

Current occupation Member

University/Institution Complutense University of Madrid

Address Cdad. Universitaria

Postal code 28040 Madrid

Telephone 0034 913945798

Email l.bachmaier@der.ucm.es