In the wake of Pupino: Advocaten voor der Wereld and Dell'Orto

This paper argues that the third pillar, despite the ECJ’s landmark ruling of Pupino (which extended communautaire reasoning to the third pillar terrain) is and remains different from the supranational sphere. In so doing, the paper asks whether a consistent approach to EU law can be derived from the orthodoxy of EC law by focussing on the recent judgments of Advocaten voor de Wereld and Dell’Orto.

Journal/Publisher: German Law Journal, Volume 8, Issue 12

Publication type: Article

Number of pages/Page range: 1147-1160

Language/s (content): English

Date of publication: 03-12-07

Personal data

Full name Ester HERLIN-KARNELL

Current occupation Member

University/Institution VU University Amsterdam

Address De Boelelaan 1105

Postal code 1081 HV

Telephone 0031 205989652

Fax 0031 20598 6300

Email e.herlinkarnell@vu.nl